By Fr. Gerald Goodrum, S.T.L.
Perhaps the most notorious and oft-quoted example of Senator Kennedy's miscomprehension of a well-formed conscience and the proper disposition of a person of faith from his "Ministerial Association Speech" is the following statement: "I believe in a president whose religious views are his own private affair, neither imposed by him upon the nation, [nor] imposed by the nation upon him as a condition to holding that office." In stating that it is neither the right of the president nor of the United States to dictate which religion if any to practice, he is correct and in line with the Constitution.
However, he sets up once again another false dichotomy and this time between "private" and "public" regarding the most important issue in the universe: namely, one's faith or lack of faith in God.
JFK's formulation is part of the contemporary wellspring of the "split-personality complex" manifested when a politician who is Christian professes to be "personally or privately opposed but publicly for" some gravely immoral issue. Religion as merely a private affair means that one's religious faith has no practical sway on one's thoughts, behaviors, or actions. It means that religion does not teach nor does it shape one's character or inform one's decisions.
[ Click here to read more. ]